Our Story

Hi, I’m Sophie!

I’m the Sales Director behind Mary Lou’s Custom Cookies and the face helping bring our custom cookies to the Indianapolis area.

Mary Lou’s Donuts has been a small, local West Lafayette bakery since 1961 and has been a part of my life for years. Waldon, the owner and a longtime family friend, saw an opportunity to take the freshly made cookies people already love and make them completely customizable. Knowing my love for connecting with people, sales, and all things creative, he asked me to help bring that vision to life and grow Mary Lou’s Custom Cookies throughout the Indy area.

What makes us different is that we’re not a factory or a mass-production cookie company. Every order starts at our local bakery, where the cookies are freshly baked and crafted specifically for you. From there, we can personalize them with your logos, photos, QR codes, wording, event designs, and just about anything else you can dream up.

My favorite part is working directly with each customer from the first idea to the final cookie. Whether it’s for a business, wedding, birthday, grand opening, game day, or just because, the goal is simple: create something that looks amazing, tastes even better, and feels completely you.

Freshly crafted. Completely custom. Uniquely yours.