Make it Memorable
Your Ideas
Make it Unique
Bring Creativity to Your Event
Create
Check out some of our most recent custom creations! From logos and celebrations to special events, see what we’ve been baking lately.

Our Latest Creations

Media image 1
MEET SOPHIE

The Girl Behind the Cookies

Hi, I'm Sophie! I am the Sales Director behind Mary Lou's Custom Cookies and the face helping bring our cookies to the Indy area. I love connecting with people, bringing creative ideas to life, and making the little details of an event feel extra special. From the first idea to the final cookie, I am here to help create something that feels uniquely you!

Media image 2
Real Reviews

THE SWEETEST FEEDBACK

We could tell you how good our cookies are, but we think our customers say it better. Custom-made, freshly crafted, and created to make every event a little sweeter.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

I have a design idea, but I don’t see it on your website. What should I do?
Send it my way! You’re definitely not limited to what you see on our website. Send me a photo, logo, color scheme, wording, or even a half-baked idea (pun intended), and I’ll help bring it to life. I respond back QUICK —no waiting three business days around here.
How far in advance should I place my order?
The earlier, the better—especially for larger orders or busy weekends! But if you’re reading this thinking, “Oops… my event is next week,” don’t panic. Reach out anyway! If we can make it happen, we absolutely will.
What if I don’t live in the Indianapolis area?
I personally deliver many of our custom orders. But don’t let a little distance get between you and your cookies! Delivery options are available! Send me your location and order details, and we’ll figure out the best way to get your cookies where they need to go.
Who will I work with when placing my order?
Hi, that’s me! I’m Sophie, and you’ll work directly with me throughout the custom ordering process. I help with your ideas, create the designs, coordinate everything with our bakery team, and can even deliver your finished cookies. I may not be the one holding the mixing bowl, but my job is to make the whole process easy, personal, and stress-free from idea to cookie.